Think about the critical reading skills you’ve practiced this year throughout the poetry unit and throughout The Awakening unit. Many of you indicated—via the last blog’s goals—that you wish to further develop these skills by annotating, fondling the details, etc. How have those skills helped you read through the research materials you’ve found? Do you find yourself reading the research materials differently? Have you researched for this essay differently than you have for other essays after hearing the research tips that Mrs. Bontrager presented? Reflect upon your growth as a reader and as a researcher.
Finally, let the rest of the class know what topic you're researching! Feel free to comment on others' topics.
Wednesday, October 8, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

13 comments:
After listening to Mrs. Bontrager's presentation, I do find myself executing my research process differently. In the past, I have relied heavily on Wikipedia and googling my topic to find information or links to various sources. Now, as this has been deemed unacceptable, I must change my methods. I have not carefully read through my materials at this point, so I remain unaware how the presentation and my critical reading skills will affect this aspect of my research paper. I briefly skimmed through the two CQ Researcher packets I found to be relevant to my topic, and them to be highly interesting and full of exceedingly useful information for my paper. I am optimistic about this project, and I look forward to achieving my goals in this paper and future papers. I plan to do my paper on obesity and its effects on the general population.
Throughout the Awakening unit, I feel that I have really improved on "fondling the details" and digging deeper into the text. So far, my critical reading skills and Mrs. Bontrager's presentation have helped me in finding credible sources for my topic. Instead, like with many of my previous essays, I tend not to ensure that the site is credible. Now, I have tools to make sure they are true to what they say. Mrs. Bontrager's presentation helped me, especially when she discussed the CQ researcher. I think that I have come a long way in terms of a researcher and as a reader. I look for the details more and read through the whole text, looking for the important points. I plan to write my paper on how images in advertisements of "beautiful people" affect teenage girls.
I also found Mrs. Bontrager's presentation helpful. I looked up the CQ Researcher after she told us about it and it really helped me to research my topic. The information has dates on it so you know if it is out of date and it is relatively easy to find something on your topic. The only set back is that it has only a certain amount of information and topics so it is likely that your topic will not be on there. I have also found the inspire website to be extremely helpful, it is full of reliable sourses that directly relate to your topic. Upon starting my research, I have found that I have been looking deeper into the articles and not just scaning them for main ideas. This will especially help me when I get further along on the paper and I want to have accurate evidence. My paper is about how smoking cigarettes can tear families apart.
Thanks to Mrs. Bontrager’s presentation and Miss Stump’s intense teaching of the necessity of critical reading, I feel confident in my ability to research information and comprehend what it is saying. I am beginning to rely less on googling and more on the data bases that are supplied to us student. These data bases offer more reliable resources, thus minimizing the risk for untrue content in my paper. I also feel as though I am striving to search for more in depth sources as compared to sources that just cover surface issues. This will help to develop my argument, as I am writing my paper over the very controversial topic of abortion. My paper will discuss how the number of abortions every year has dramatically risen over the past half a century. By using my newly acquired critical reading skills and research methods, I hope to develop a convincing and valid argument.
I have definitely improved on my critical reading skills. I have carried my progress over from The Awakening unit to this research paper. My topic is the AIDS epidemic currently affecting Africa. After Mrs. Bontrager's presentation, I have used two CQ Researcher articles, which have come in handy a lot already. After further developing my critical reading skills I have found that I am more confident in my researching skills as well. I feel as though I can effectively choose reliable sources and weed out those which may not be valid. I can choose points which will further my argument. Hopefully, throughout this project, I can develop these skills even more and continue to improve.
My critical reading skills have helped me to research thoroughly and more in-depth. As I collected a few sources for my causal argument paper, I was careful to read between the lines to discover what each source was truly about. Instead of just using Google to find internet articles, I have utilized CQ Researcher and Inspire to find more academic sources. I have tried to find a variety of types of sources such as newspapers, magazines, books, and internet articles. I think when I collect all my sources I will be able to use the critical reading skills I have developed during The Awakening unit. When organizing my material, I will need to read for details and specific answers to my argument that birth order affects personality, lifestyle, and success.
The skills i have developed have helped me to better understand the sources im using for my research. i now find myself analyzing the details in my research and applying what i find to my paper. i dont think that im reseaching differently because of what Mrs. Bontrager said. i dont really find it necessary to use databases to find quality information. i find now that i am reading more attentively, and i am recognizing, in my research, that i make sure to undercover the credibility of my sources. I am researching the effect of the liberal bias of the media on the American people.
I feel as if after reading The Awakening I have begun to more closely examine details. Although the presentation we received was rather helpful; I am still having trouble finding all of the important details that I feel are necessary to construct a convincing paper. This may be because I am too critical of all the sources that I find, or there is not much information truly out there for my specific topic. Overall, I feel that I am slowly becoming a more critical reader and writer thanks to our wonderful AP English teacher, Miss Stump! For my paper I am writing about money and income, and its effects on our lives.
I feel that not much has changed in my research style or the way I read sources. I've always avoided internet sources (mainlybecause they are difficult to properly cite)and looked for sources that were considered to be the most credible. As far as looking for details, my topic choices for most of my previous papers have often required me to look for minute details within a whole work that support my argument or research. I often have to look very closely to find evidence that supports my specific topic. Overall, I feel like much of my research style has merely been confirmed by what we've learned in the past week.
I forgot to include my topic. I'll be writing about the failure of the No Child Left Behind Act, and the causes of its inability to reach its goals in education.
As for myself, I have really been working on critically reading my own research. The support I will use in my paper has been read, re-read, annotated, questioned, and thoroughly examined. :] Even though I am using my fellow "blogger" opinions, they are valued to me because they support my topic: the effects of students blogging. The research is hard to obtain because this is not a topic that is observed and critiqued. So I really am going on a limb with this paper...but no one has written about this topic yet so I look forward to writing this essay. Yahoo for blogging!!
Following the common trend of googling for research, I too often fell victim to the lure of Wikipedia and other unreliable websites. I already suspected these types of sources should not be used for research papers, and Mrs. Bontrager's presentation provided sufficient confirmation. Although I doubt that I will be able to totally kick my Wikipedia addiction cold turky, I plan to totally avoid those websites during my formal research. I think I am going to enjoy researching and writing the causal argument because of the new annotating and critical reading skills I am acquiring through this course. I decided to write about the causes of eating disorders, specifically anorexia nervosa, because it interests me. Also, many people tend to be mistaken about the controversal topic.
Although I should be researching differently then what I have in the past, I have not changed how I am researching. I continue to skim through the information to see if it has any useful information. I find it difficult to use sites like Inspire, so I avoid using that site or ones similar to it. I have never been a good researcher; I do not know how to improve research skills. My topic is the affects of a bad economy on people's lives.
Post a Comment