Tuesday, November 18, 2008
Trimester Two, Blog One (Period 2, due 11/23 at midnight)
Comment on a tragic hero outside of Hamlet and Shakespeare’s plays. Identify the tragic hero and include some thoughts on what qualifies that character as a tragic hero. If you choose not to identify your own tragic hero, you may comment on another student’s choice through support or disagreement.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

11 comments:
Michael Jordan: the man that everyone loved, admired, and dreamed to be, until he made a joke of himself in his return to basketball in 2001. After he won his sixth NBA Finals championship, he was known by many as the greatest basketball player ever. He won five regular season MVP awards and six NBA Finals MVPs. Jordan was on top of the world. He perfectly retired then, when it was almost impossible to gain more respect that he already had. Alas, he had one major flaw that kept him from walking away as the greatest player ever: he had an urge to keep on playing even when he knew he didn't have much left. He decided to return to the NBA in 2001, playing for 2 seasons with the Washington Wizards. His stats and gameplay dropped drastically. He was greatly criticized for his return. Most people believed this short stint blemished his other wise nearly perfect career. Jordan had a chance to retire as the best player in NBA history, but his later comeback put doubts in some people's minds as whether or not they could still say the same. This fall from grace is truly sad, considering that he just might be the greatest to ever play.
I agree with Trent's identification of Michael Jordan as a tragic hero. While I feel that the phrase "making a joke of himself" is a bit extreme, his return to the game of basketball certainly was a sort of fall from grace. Jordan certainly fits the description of a tragic hero as someone of nobility or high stature, as the American society as a whole tends to idolize and even attempt to emulate professional athletes. As for the flaw that Trent identified, I am not convinced that loving something would constitute a flaw in many situations beyond this one. For Michael Jordan's case, however, his desire to continue playing and his subsequent return to the NBA certainly led to his downfall, albeit on a smaller scale.
I feel that John F. Kennedy is a strong example of a tragic hero. A war veteran and an admired president, Kennedy never failed to win the hearts of the American people. He worked diligently for his people and for his country, implementing economic programs that still thrive today. He fought relentlessly for civil rights and equality, something Abraham Lincoln would have greatly applauded. Preceding his death, he laid plans for a massive assault on persisting areas of privation and poverty. On November 22, 1963, the hearts of the American people mourned. It was on this day that JFK was assassinated while appearing in a parade in Dallas, Texas. America's beloved president was murdered, forever leaving his people bitter.
A good example for a modern day tragic hero would be Michael Vick. At one point a great athlete, he no longer plays in the NFL due to his genius acts of illegal dog fighting. His impressive athleticism made him a quality quarterback and a person of high status throughout the league. However, his choice to break the law certainly swayed the opinions of his fans. This flaw would postpone, if not terminate his playing in the NFL. Now, he has lost his endorsements and is no longer the super star he had potential to be. This tragic hero has certainly encountered a downfall.
The book(or movie) Atonement presents a tragic hero in the form of Robbie Turner. For those of you who haven't read the book the plot is as follows. Robbie is son of a servant of the wealthy Tallis family; he has grown up amongst the 3 Tallis children Leon, Cecilia, and Briony. As the children grew the youngest, Briony, formed an attachment to the much older Robbie that she would interpert as love. Unfortunately when Robbie does not reciprocate these feelings, 11 year old Briony becomes increasingly frustrated. Ironically, in fact, Robbie falls for the beautiful and distant Cecilia. In a decision that would lead to this tragic hero's fall, Robbie writes a letter to Cecilia describing his love. However, the letter he gives to Briony to deliver to her sister is a crude earlier version he had not meant for Cecilia to see, or Briony for that matter. In a display of curiosity and anger Briony opens the letter and misconstrues the situation. She believes Robbie is afflicted by perversion and wishes to rape her sister. Eventually, this letter is shown to the rest of the Tallis household leading to Robbie's imprisonment and draft into World War II. In the end, both Robbie and Cecilia die in the carnage and aftermath of war, leaving Briony with a crime of childhood innocence to face an impending "Atonement".
I can not think of a tragic hero off of the top of my head, but I agree with Tori in the fact that JFK was a tragic hero. When he first started out, the American people loved him; they really thought he was going to do alot of good in this country. Unfortunately, tragic heros end up in tragic situations, and JFk was one of them. Although he left many good things behind, I think that if he would of lived, we would have so many better things in this country that he was never able to establish.
I feel that a more recent tragic hero is Dale Earnhardt. He was the most influential man in the NASCAR world. He obtained a reputation around the sport as a love him or hate him type of a guy. His driving style earned him the nickname The Intimidator and that same style of racing is what grew his fan base to the largest the sport has ever seen. Earnhardt used his status with the fans to push the NASCAR board of directors to make the sport more fan friendly.
However his life was tragically cut short on the final lap of the Daytona 500 in 2001. NASCAR recommended that drivers wear safety devices, but he ignored them. After his death the sport began to improve safety regulations, which is one of the most noticeable things that has come of his death. Drivers were mandated to wear HANS devices which would help to keep their head and neck from moving during a hard impact. NASCAR also placed a foam padded wall on the outside of the concrete walls which would reduce the impact shock for a head-on collision into a wall. The sport was forced to learn a lesson the hard way, and if they had only increased safety measures beforehand then this could have been avoided.
A modern day tragic hero that I would like to talk about is Walter Payton. He was loved by millions of Chicago Bears fans around the United States. Payton to this day holds the 2nd most rushing yards in a single season and holds first place for the most rushes lead in an NFL career. Walter Payton was said to be one of the most well liked football players of all time. Payton tragically died at the age of 45 of cancer. After his death the Chicago Bears retired the number 34 jersey forever. I believe that this man, to this day, is considered one of the most tragic sports deaths in all of pro sports.
I definately agree with Brock on the choice of Michael Vick. As an NFL quarterback, Vick had it all. Money, fame, publicity, but he let it all go in one poor choice. His choice to partake in illegal dogfighting led to his fall from glory and into prison. He disgraced his name, reputation, and the NFL by making a poor choice. A seemingly good man with a tragic character flaw, A.K.A. tragic hero.
Though it may sound cliche, I feel that Heath Ledger would represent a modern day hero. The actor was well-known worldwide, not to mention highly praised for his work. Ledger was a great actor of our time, preparing for one of his biggest and most extreme roles, ultimately bringing him to his tragic end. Because of his persistence in acing his character and providing the most exact replica of the Joker, Ledger became wrapped in the character; furthermore, he faced a struggle within himself to break away from character when film was no longer rolling. Yet Ledger was not strong enough, emotionally, to fight off the character's personality, as it haunted him, leading to his public overdose. Though Ledger was merely an actor struck with an tragic early death, he remains a hero in the sense that he fought for his status, but like all tragic heroes, he picked a battle in which he could not win.
I agree with Brock and George one hundred percent! Mike Vick was a legendary person in the NFL. He could run, throw, and evade defenders left and right. He can do none of this from his jail cell. A man of his stature fighting dogs is absurd. He could possible make a return, but I believe his dog fighting was the end of football for Vick. The Atlana Falcons should probably sign Titus. The Chaz Man
Post a Comment