Take some time to reflect on the Hamlet Project. What worked well? What didn’t? What strengths did each group display? Overall, what are your thoughts on this project, and what might you change for the future?
13 comments:
Anonymous
said...
Well, as far as Shakespeare goes, I thought the project worked pretty well. I think we all [at least the group I was in] were sort of unsure of what we were doing at first, and maybe spent too much time trying to figure that out, but I did feel like things kind of fell into place the day of the "trial." I think that my group could have been more prepared as far as responses to questions and the legal procedures used in a court of law, but it worked out. I think that we were a decent group, and we listened well to each other's input. I thought that the defense team obviously was prepared for the legal proceedings, and that they had good, scripted out answers. Overall, it was an entertaining project and a nice break from sitting in a classroom. Plus I got to wear a crown. :)
I enjoyed this project very much. As Katherine said, it got us out of the normal classroom setting and let us work on a unique project that allowed us to look at Hamlet in a new perspective. Both sides seemed to work together very well as a team in order to do their best. Both sides also used great examples and textual evidence to get their points across. I think that both of the teams probably should have prepared better for cross examination questions. It seemed like everyone was up there winging it when they were being questioned by the opposing side. I think there is one little way to make it a bit more exciting. Record the trial and show it to a jury made up of various teachers. Have them vote to decide whether Hamlet is guilty or innocent, and the winning team gets a few bonus points. Other than that, I believe that the project is just fine the way it is.
I feel as though the project was fairly confusing at first, but that could just be me, due to the fact that I am a visual learner. Although I was only present for part of the trial, I felt that everything did sort of fall into place. I learned that I should never (ever, ever, ever) attempt to pose as a witness to any case, ever. Unless I'm just incompetent, I found the prosecution's attorney to be rather confusing and slightly out of line. This could have been prepared and expected a little more on our part as the defense. One aspect that I feel led to the outcome of the project was that because most of our work was pre-planned by another group member (which is fine) the rest of us were not as well-informed or involved as we may have been otherwise, possibly leading to some of the confusion.
I enjoyed the project as well and felt it was a great way to shed new light onto Hamlet. I think that both groups were well prepared, however a little extra preparation time would have been nice. I had written all my questions that were to be asked of me by the prosecution, but I didn't have time to search for possible cross-examination questions. It also would have been nice if both group's attorneys would have been given basic information on legal procedures. It was obvious that the defense knew more about legal procedures, which really hurt the prosecution's chances of preparing counter-arguments. All-in-all I felt that the project was a fun experience and it should be continued next year, with the added preparation time included.
I feel that the Hamlet project helped us to somewhat understand Shakespeare writing better, but i felt that certain members in the group were at an advantage to learn more than others. I felt that elysia's group was very deceptive, because women are deceptive in general. I felt they had more textual evidence in the trial, but they did not prepare their witnesses. i thought that is was JUST a project and not real life. Some people, who shall remain nameless, took this project to the most extreme extent of seriousness.
First off, I enjoyed doing this project much more than just sitting in the classroom and also learned more about the book in the process. In my group, the workload was slightly unequal. For me, I felt that our witnesses were not very prepared for the cross-examination by the prosecuting side. In my opinion, the questions were hard to answer because I did not want to misquote myself. The project as a whole was better, but it was very hard to defend Hamlet because he admitted to murder and treason. I feel Elysia, and basically only Elysia, prepared our group really well, but I also think the other group did a good job with the questioning of the witnesses. I had fun with the project and hope to do more like this in the future.
The Hamlet project was not exactly what I had expected to go out with after finishing the book. I feel like it didn't do much to cover what was read and the witnesses were ill-prepared (including myself) as far as arguing their case. Although it was nice to step away from the routine for a week, I have no better understanding of the play. Yeah, I didn't mind it, but I think the groups should discuss more than their scripts and should review their character's role before posing as a witness
I agree somewhat with Taylor and Trent, in the fact that it was incredibly difficult for those posing as witnesses during a crossexamination. We (the group I was in) definitely could have done a much better job in preparing their witnesses. That we faced this problem, however, could be beneficial for future participants. Perhaps, for the future, the groups could have some kind of layout as to what they should do. I know that the only reason my group appeared better prepared is because both Chaz and myself had knowledge of legal proceedings due to past classes. All in all, the project was fun, and like Katherine said, it was nice to get away from the class room setting.
I beg to disagree with Wes, however. Women are not deceptive. We are just more clever than men. I know, it takes some getting used to.
I felt this project was very fun. I enjoyed the group work and finally getting to work with Elysia and understanding that she gets better grades cause she prepares herself. But, yes Brock we got destroyed by the cross exams. I would have liked to watch a court case first prior to this. It was fun dressing up in that gangster suit I had and laughing and enjoying George in a white hood with crown. I do like law aswell so I found it fun to act as if I was really a lawyer or whatever I was. I am anxious to hear the verdict as Ms. Stump will be absent due to her trip to Africa. Thanks for the reminder to do this Brock your a hero, a guitar hero! xoxox Chaz
I also enjoyed this project. I thought that the trials went relatively well for the time that we were allowed. I think that if we had been given more time, and perhaps a little lesson about law, we would have been a little more prepared. In the end though, it was pretty entertaining and a good end to Hamlet. I enjoyed doing a group project rather than an individual project or a test. I also think that by being a character, I was able to analyze that character and I at least know a little bit more about the play. I also think that the trial helped us to get a better understanding of what happened in the book.
I liked the Hamlet "project" in the aspect that it gave everyone in the class to interact with each other and show how much we had learned or in some cases didn't learn. I liked that everyone took it seriously in that they wanted to win the case for their team, but everyone had that sense of playfulness. In my group everyone did a good job of communicating and helping each other out when needed. The other team did a good job of having Elysia. The dressing up definitely made the project more enjoyable. I really wouldn't change anything about this project I felt that it was one of the funnest things I have ever done in an English class.
Overall, at the beginning of the whole Hamlet section, I must admit that I was not extremely excited. As the the project progressed, however, I found myself enjoying the play and movie. The court case was also enjoyable and even though things were not always done according to the rule of law, it was fun to experience. Our group also got along well and had fun with it and from the looks of it, the other group had a good time as well. Getting out of the normal classroom learning environment was also much appreciated and nice. Overall, Hamlet was a fun and enjoyable project which honestly I never thought I would say.
I honestly enjoyed this project because it was unexpected, original, and simply fun. It allowed our class to split into bigger groups than normal, which allotted more opinions and ideas than normal group projects. It also forced us to work together to develop a plan, complete our tasks, and accomplish our goal. Because the trial involved competition (which is something to which teenagers respond extremely well), we took this project more seriously, or we attained greater motivation, at least. I only wish that we could have seen a model of organization for the project.
13 comments:
Well, as far as Shakespeare goes, I thought the project worked pretty well. I think we all [at least the group I was in] were sort of unsure of what we were doing at first, and maybe spent too much time trying to figure that out, but I did feel like things kind of fell into place the day of the "trial." I think that my group could have been more prepared as far as responses to questions and the legal procedures used in a court of law, but it worked out. I think that we were a decent group, and we listened well to each other's input. I thought that the defense team obviously was prepared for the legal proceedings, and that they had good, scripted out answers. Overall, it was an entertaining project and a nice break from sitting in a classroom. Plus I got to wear a crown.
:)
I enjoyed this project very much. As Katherine said, it got us out of the normal classroom setting and let us work on a unique project that allowed us to look at Hamlet in a new perspective. Both sides seemed to work together very well as a team in order to do their best. Both sides also used great examples and textual evidence to get their points across. I think that both of the teams probably should have prepared better for cross examination questions. It seemed like everyone was up there winging it when they were being questioned by the opposing side. I think there is one little way to make it a bit more exciting. Record the trial and show it to a jury made up of various teachers. Have them vote to decide whether Hamlet is guilty or innocent, and the winning team gets a few bonus points. Other than that, I believe that the project is just fine the way it is.
I feel as though the project was fairly confusing at first, but that could just be me, due to the fact that I am a visual learner. Although I was only present for part of the trial, I felt that everything did sort of fall into place. I learned that I should never (ever, ever, ever) attempt to pose as a witness to any case, ever. Unless I'm just incompetent, I found the prosecution's attorney to be rather confusing and slightly out of line. This could have been prepared and expected a little more on our part as the defense. One aspect that I feel led to the outcome of the project was that because most of our work was pre-planned by another group member (which is fine) the rest of us were not as well-informed or involved as we may have been otherwise, possibly leading to some of the confusion.
I enjoyed the project as well and felt it was a great way to shed new light onto Hamlet. I think that both groups were well prepared, however a little extra preparation time would have been nice. I had written all my questions that were to be asked of me by the prosecution, but I didn't have time to search for possible cross-examination questions. It also would have been nice if both group's attorneys would have been given basic information on legal procedures. It was obvious that the defense knew more about legal procedures, which really hurt the prosecution's chances of preparing counter-arguments. All-in-all I felt that the project was a fun experience and it should be continued next year, with the added preparation time included.
I feel that the Hamlet project helped us to somewhat understand Shakespeare writing better, but i felt that certain members in the group were at an advantage to learn more than others. I felt that elysia's group was very deceptive, because women are deceptive in general. I felt they had more textual evidence in the trial, but they did not prepare their witnesses. i thought that is was JUST a project and not real life. Some people, who shall remain nameless, took this project to the most extreme extent of seriousness.
First off, I enjoyed doing this project much more than just sitting in the classroom and also learned more about the book in the process. In my group, the workload was slightly unequal. For me, I felt that our witnesses were not very prepared for the cross-examination by the prosecuting side. In my opinion, the questions were hard to answer because I did not want to misquote myself. The project as a whole was better, but it was very hard to defend Hamlet because he admitted to murder and treason. I feel Elysia, and basically only Elysia, prepared our group really well, but I also think the other group did a good job with the questioning of the witnesses. I had fun with the project and hope to do more like this in the future.
The Hamlet project was not exactly what I had expected to go out with after finishing the book. I feel like it didn't do much to cover what was read and the witnesses were ill-prepared (including myself) as far as arguing their case. Although it was nice to step away from the routine for a week, I have no better understanding of the play. Yeah, I didn't mind it, but I think the groups should discuss more than their scripts and should review their character's role before posing as a witness
I agree somewhat with Taylor and Trent, in the fact that it was incredibly difficult for those posing as witnesses during a crossexamination. We (the group I was in) definitely could have done a much better job in preparing their witnesses. That we faced this problem, however, could be beneficial for future participants. Perhaps, for the future, the groups could have some kind of layout as to what they should do. I know that the only reason my group appeared better prepared is because both Chaz and myself had knowledge of legal proceedings due to past classes.
All in all, the project was fun, and like Katherine said, it was nice to get away from the class room setting.
I beg to disagree with Wes, however.
Women are not deceptive.
We are just more clever than men.
I know, it takes some getting used to.
I felt this project was very fun. I enjoyed the group work and finally getting to work with Elysia and understanding that she gets better grades cause she prepares herself. But, yes Brock we got destroyed by the cross exams. I would have liked to watch a court case first prior to this. It was fun dressing up in that gangster suit I had and laughing and enjoying George in a white hood with crown. I do like law aswell so I found it fun to act as if I was really a lawyer or whatever I was. I am anxious to hear the verdict as Ms. Stump will be absent due to her trip to Africa. Thanks for the reminder to do this Brock your a hero, a guitar hero! xoxox Chaz
I also enjoyed this project. I thought that the trials went relatively well for the time that we were allowed. I think that if we had been given more time, and perhaps a little lesson about law, we would have been a little more prepared. In the end though, it was pretty entertaining and a good end to Hamlet. I enjoyed doing a group project rather than an individual project or a test. I also think that by being a character, I was able to analyze that character and I at least know a little bit more about the play. I also think that the trial helped us to get a better understanding of what happened in the book.
I liked the Hamlet "project" in the aspect that it gave everyone in the class to interact with each other and show how much we had learned or in some cases didn't learn. I liked that everyone took it seriously in that they wanted to win the case for their team, but everyone had that sense of playfulness. In my group everyone did a good job of communicating and helping each other out when needed. The other team did a good job of having Elysia. The dressing up definitely made the project more enjoyable. I really wouldn't change anything about this project I felt that it was one of the funnest things I have ever done in an English class.
Overall, at the beginning of the whole Hamlet section, I must admit that I was not extremely excited. As the the project progressed, however, I found myself enjoying the play and movie. The court case was also enjoyable and even though things were not always done according to the rule of law, it was fun to experience. Our group also got along well and had fun with it and from the looks of it, the other group had a good time as well. Getting out of the normal classroom learning environment was also much appreciated and nice. Overall, Hamlet was a fun and enjoyable project which honestly I never thought I would say.
I honestly enjoyed this project because it was unexpected, original, and simply fun. It allowed our class to split into bigger groups than normal, which allotted more opinions and ideas than normal group projects. It also forced us to work together to develop a plan, complete our tasks, and accomplish our goal. Because the trial involved competition (which is something to which teenagers respond extremely well), we took this project more seriously, or we attained greater motivation, at least. I only wish that we could have seen a model of organization for the project.
Post a Comment