Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Trimester Two, Blog Six (due 1/25 at midnight)

Reread page 487 in Everything’s an Argument (you should have already read it when you read Chapter 16). Provide your own example of a situation and its context in which evidence other than hard, factual evidence is just as, if not more, advantageous. The example you provide can be one based on a real experience (such as the one noted in the book), or you can formulate your own hypothetical experience. Address, as necessary, the rationale for the evidence you believe to be the most persuasive.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

Going along with the example in the book, a conversation between a devout Christian and an atheist or agnostic person would serve as an example of evidence that is not hard and factual. The atheist could argue that while the Bible does exist, there is no proof that its contents are even remotely true. The atheist/agnostic could also point out that the Bible was written by a collection of authors, who would certainly struggle to mesh their beliefs and viewpoints. The atheist/agnostic could also point out the lack of physical evidence that God exists and that Jesus was his son who performed many miracles. The devout Christian, however, could point to the Bible and say that it is God's word, simply written down by humans. The same person could also call the many miracles and random acts of kindness that occur every day evidence of the presence of God, saying that one's faith is what causes these instances to be solid evidence.
Obviously, this evidence isn't 100% persuasive--if it was, there would be no such thing as atheism. However, in the right circumstance with the right person, the above evidence could be extremely persuasive.

$~young broc~$ said...

Suppose a man, (his name can be Adam), said he was better at ping pong that another man (his name can be Chad). Adam would use hard evidence to support his claim, saying he has statistically won more games. Also, when Adam wins it is by a decent margin. Chad, however, claims that he is better because he is more consistent and rarely has a bad game, while Adam tends to have off and on good games. Friends of Adam and Chad agree that Chad is better. Adam uses hard facts to argue his point, but Chad uses his friends’ opinions and his rationale to make his statement. While both arguments have valid data, Chad has more persuasive points. He has the evidence of multiple opinions compared to the single opinion of Adam. Adam will struggle in this argument because his hard facts are less reliable than the testimonies of Chad’s friends. However, both can say they are good players and the argument would be hard to close.

Trent Stutzman said...

Cy Young by far has the most career wins as a pitcher with 511. The next closest is Walter Johnson with 417. One might use this hard evidence to claim that Young is the greatest pitcher of all time. Upon further examination, however, it becomes much harder to make this proclamation. Although no one else is even close to his win total, he played during a time in which pitchers pitched every three days. Now days, pitchers only go every five days. This gives him numerous more chances to record a win. He also played during what is known as the "dead ball era" in which there were very few talented hitters, which also helps boost his stats, since he played against weeker competition. Some could argue that maybe Nolan Ryan or Roger Clemens is the greatest pitcher of all time, since they also have impressive stats but they did it during a time with better hitters and fewer opportunities to record their stats. No single piece of evidence can convince everyone on who the greatest pitcher is, but these reasons can help give people a more educated view.

Time for some Chazzle Dazzle said...

I like football and will go with that topic. Say a football fan of Notre Dame claims they are the best team in college football. A USC fan makes the same claim as well. Both could have qualtiy evidence. The Dame fan could claim that his team has the most wins in college football ever. The USC fan could counterargue and point out that the past few years for ND have been mediocre five hundred seasons and that USC has posted four Rose Bowl wins in the past five years and also ranks near the top in all time wins. The year and diffuclty of schedule could factor in this argument and can change ever year. However, personally as of lately I would say USC has the upper hand and no I am not a USC fan. Go VT Hookies!!

Anonymous said...

Following this example we can bring this viewpoint to a teacher's perspective. For instance, teachers can interpret hard factual evidence by a student's test performance. Such examples include ISTEP, grades and test scores, IQ tests, and many more. As a teacher,a student's learning should not be evaluated solely on test scores. For example, a child may have low test scores, but still have accomplished a great deal of learning; however, while a student with high test scores may show that they know the content, may not represent their effort put forth or their amount learned compared to the first student. Also teachers have to look at the emotional stability of the child, because a child's learning can be affected by many different things such as, home life, friendships, and self esteem. This is why grades and test scores should not be used as a sole measure of student learning or teacher effectiveness.

Brett said...

A situation where hard evidence would not be useful would be in that of which soda tastes better, Coke or Pepsi? If one would research sales statistics over the past 50 years, they would find that both companies are in a deadlock, together the companies make up over 98% of the total market with both holding 49% (+/- 4%.) So, the only logical way to determine which soda tastes better would be to have consumers taste each and select one or to have them fill out a questionnaire. The downside to these sources of evidence is that they focus on a small group of participants in a selected area. However, since sales and other miscellaneous data that the companies conduct does not provide enough information, these tests are the only true way that this market can be judged.

George said...

An example I would like to use is the question who is the all time greatest home run hitter of all time? While there are many candidates there are two which stick out the most. Sammy Sosa and Babe Ruth are two of the greatest home run hitters of all time but who is the best? While some people may believe that with the statistics Babe Ruth is the best. Taking in the account of how many each home runs each player has hit and the total number of years each was in the league the statistics clearly point to Babe Ruth. Some people may argue the fact that the MLB has become more competitive in the almost 100 year difference of each players prime. Cubs fans would say that the techniques and genetics of old players are nothing compared to the players of today's age. Although this is true Babe Ruth was not on steroids as was Sammy Sosa. The extra boost that Sosa got from "Mr. Steroids" clearly demotes him from even being in the running for the all time greatest home run hitter. Babe Ruth is and always will be the greatest home run hitter of all time.

Hrothgar Vilhelm said...

Arguments in which personal opinions and tastes matter require evidence that is anything but hard. Take for example the debate over which car is better, a ferrari or a lamborghini? One could argue that either car is better than the other. Statistically speaking, both cars are similar in relevant aspects such as horsepower, price, top speed, size, and performance, however, which car a person prefers depends mostly on their personal preference. You cannot statistically argue that one car is more beautiful than another because people's opinions differ. One may argue that the ferrari is more beautiful but the evidence they offer could be used by a person arguing in favor of the lamborghini. No one can factually prove that one car is more desirable than another because people will buy what they find attractive, not what they think everyone else likes. Especially when that something costs 100,000 dollars.

Chuck Norris has brass cahonas said...

To kind of take a different spin on Trent's example, i will discuss who is the greatest home run hitter of all time. If i was to use raw, hard, facts, i would say that Barry Bonds is the greatest home run hitter of all time because he has hit the most home runs at 762. Although this is the hard fact, most would argue that he wasn't the greatest. During his play in the major leagues, many speculations arose about Bonds taking steroids in order to improve his home run numbers. Because of this, people, who know the game, reason that the actual greats were Ruth and Aaron. Most think that these two are better, because they made their huge achievements in a time before hard weight training regiments and performance-enhancing drugs; these players relied on skill alone. The non factual evidence is not completely superior because Bonds and steroids is just a speculation, of which he has never been proven guilty. The popular opinion, though, is definitely against the hard facts which grow less and less persuasive.

kinz said...

Any argument involving two opposing sides attempting to prove their similar yet unique products as "the best" will ultimately require evidence supplementary to facts or statistics. This is because the decision of the greatest between two brands ultimately depends on opinions. For example, the issue of sunscreen arose during Spring Break last year as two sisters clashed over the exellence of their specific brands. When comparing sunscreens, one must consider a multitude of qualities such as effectiveness, pricing, absorbance, appearence, endurance, etc; while one sunbather may desire a pleasantly scented sunscreen over a lotion that lasts throughout a swim, an athlete would most likely prefer the latter. All these matters heated the sisters' assessment, and it eventually evolved to a "Mine is just better!" type of argument. In order to calm their dispute, I suggested a poll of all the guests in our beach house in order to officially account for the majority of opinions. This type of evidence allowed for personal opinions in an organized fashion.