You have two choices for this week’s blog response:
#1: Respond to the following prompt using one of the four methods described in your blog handout: Continue our class discussion of good readers by explaining how your view of a good reader has evolved over the week. Reflect upon the notes you took and the points we discussed in class to provide a detailed response here.
OR
#2: Visit the link below to view a cartoon from The New Yorker. Then, respond to the following questions: 1) How do the details of the cartoon contribute to the humor it evokes? (That’s right—fondle the details.) 2) What comment does this cartoon seem to be making about our society or about an aspect of society? 3) Why might an editor have chosen to include this particular cartoon in the August issue of The New Yorker?
http://www.newyorker.com/humor/issuecartoons/2007/08/27/cartoons_20070820?slide=5#showHeader
Wednesday, August 13, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

15 comments:
First of all...I am really hoping my computer decided to be normal & link me to the right cartoon so my response makes sense. Fingers crossed.
The man in the car seems to be driving in a fairly nice car, reminiscent of a Bentley. Just by his face, I imagine that he is some kind of investment banker with a high paying job. Based on these two assumptions, I'd call him somewhat pretentious and maybe even stuck up. I feel like his comment would be said in a very condescending tone. These details make the cartoon more humorous because here's this "big shot" getting a ticket by a blue collar worker. Maybe it's just me, but the driver's comment ("To be frank, officer, my parents never set boundaries.") makes me think that the car driver has gotten his way a lot and hasn't met much resistance in his life. The cartoon seems to be implying that kids in our society are coddled by their parents and that this lack of discipline yields less-than-upstanding citizens. The fact that the police officer doesn't seem to care at all what the driver has to say sends the message that there is no tolerance for these people. I think that an editor would choose to run this cartoon in August because it's time for everyone to start school again, and teachers all over have to deal with the kids that will grow up to be like the man in the car. I think the editor and/or cartoonist wanted to send the message that something has to be done about the way our society views and treats its youth.
Over the past week my ideas about the characteristics of a good reader have changed. Before this week I felt that in order to be a "good reader," one only had to relate to his or her book and find interest in it. However, after reading Perrine's and Nabokov's articles I have found that reading critically is something that is a necessity. A person must look at all the details and decipher what it is that he or she is reading. The advice that Nabakov and Perrine gave (such a rereading, fondling the details, and satisfying all the details) are extremely helpful suggestions in the area of critical reading. Because of reading these articles I feel like I am now more interested in analyzing what I read, and the suggestions of these two authors will enhance my ability to do so.
My thoughts about a "good reader" has not changed much over the past week. I have always reread many of the books I read. I was happy to see that Nabokov said "good readers" reread. That point was one of the only aspects of his article that I agreed with him. I do believe that one needs to pay close attention to details of the poem or article one is reading. I have begun to annotate what I read to attempt to pay attention to deatails. This has been difficult for me because many of the poems we have read I have not understood; therefore, I do not know what to write down. I have been able to pick out more figrative language as the week past.
After this week of reading and analyzing the different attributes a "good reader" should have, only a few things have changed in my opinion. Before reading Perrine and Nabokov's articles I was taught a good reader asks questions of the literature and examines it closely (which, in part, is what the two articles say) but when it comes to fondling details, I never thought of reading in that way. In Perrine's article he says, "When this new world has been closely studied, then and only then let us examine its links with other worlds, other branches of knowledge." This new world Perrine refers to is the world of literature or of an author's art. Such pieces of 'art' assist us in examining 'links with other worlds.' I really like the way Perrine describes this. It is so true that reading truly does open up new worlds, people, and experiences for those that wish to explore it. In my opinion that is the greatest thing about reading and that is what makes a great reader- when you are willing to be open to new ideas and knowledge you are a truly great reader.
Over this past week, some of my opinions of "good readers" have changed, but some have also stayed the same, just shown in a new light. I've always thought that a reader should pay close attention to the details, but have never thought to "fondle" the details. I have also thought that the reader should have somewhat of an imagination, but did not realize that the reader's imagination should be "impersonal". According to Nabokov, "the authentic instrument to be used by a good reader" is an "impersonal imagination and artistic delight". I feel that I personally have become a better reader after reading Nabokov and Perrine's opinions. I have more of an open imagination out of respect for the authors and at least attempt at an "artistic delight". One point that Nabokov made that has really transformed my reading is to "remain aloof". This really helps to notice all the details of the text and to enjoy the literature more. At least in my case :)
Well, to be honest, I never really gave much thought to what a "good reader" would consist of. Mostly, I thought a good reader was just someone who understood the material they read and were able to explain it to others. I know now that is not all being a "good reader" entails. A good reader needs to take a deeper look at what they are reading and find meaning in it. Suggestions such as re-reading and looking specifically at details are a good way to start becoming a better reader.
I know now that I need to care more about what I'm reading and dig deeper for more than just a superficial understanding. Especially if I'm to do well in AP English, I should challenge myself to become a better reader, using the characteristics we've already learned about. I believe now that using those I am better equipped to excell.
My opinion of a "good reader" has changed slightly over the week while discussing Nabokov and Perrine's articles. Nabokov has evolved my thinking more than Perrine, especially due to his statement saying that a bad reader identifies oneself with a character of the book. Before last week, I annotated very little and I seldom used my imagination to try to interpret what exactly the author was trying to convey to readers. But worst of all, I often found myself relating to one or more characters in a book. In contrast, I did look up words I was not familiar with and reread a lot. The skills the two authors expressed in their articles have helped me better understand the poems and articles we have read. I am also sure that they will further help me in the future.
A good reader, to me, is someone that is able to look at a document and not simply read it, but seriously analyze the potential of the piece. When reading these articles I have begun to better understand these principles. I have also learned to research the meaning of words I do not understand to add to my overall benefit. Therefore my reading habits and beliefs have evolved greatly over the week.
Overall, my opinion on what makes a good reader has been little changed. Much of what we've discussed this week was taught to me for English team and earlier English electives. Good memory, remaining aloof, noticing literary devices, and using an artistic sense with a scientific approach are all things that I've identified as vital to successfully reading a text for these purposes. However, using a dictionary was one point that I've always done. I remember being told by a former teacher of mine that reading expands your vocabulary, but learned on my own that it only will do so if you take the time to look up the words that are new to you. This also contributes to your understanding of the text. "Kindness to Authors" is something else that I understand, but for and entirely different reason. Being a writer myself, this practice holds a special significance. I'm somewhat familiar with the process of writing a piece and understand what an author may strive to accomplish in his or her work. Often it is not to please the reader with the most commercial of poems or stories - the plot or theme that will be most enjoyed or best for sale. As an author,your goal is more often with the text itself, and the point of the peace is more important that a readers initial reaction, for example, to the author's tone. I can connect with this, and have learned to give an author some slack in whether I "liked" the piece or not, and focussing on whether he or she accomplished his or her purpose. The main change in my thoughts on good readers is that of rereading. I've never much valued rereading a text if it was longer. I understand the idea of rereading poems and essays, but never even considered rereading a novel. Now I look back at novels that I have read and can only imagine the possibilities of better understanding the text. One novel that especially serves as an example of this is The Picture of Dorian Gray. As the year goes on, I'll likely work on rereading the texts as much as possible, when my schedule permits it.
The biggest thing that I learned from reading these articles is the importance of giving every author a fair and level opportunity to present his viewpoint. Sometimes it can be difficult to "fondle the details" of a piece when you question the authority and validity of the content (for example when you believe the author was an opiate addicted psychopath). However, if one allows their opinions of an author's personality to cloud their view of the topic, they may miss, or worse yet misunderstand, valuable tidbits of information presented in the story. I suppose, as Amy pointed out, you could tie this idea to Nabokov's "remain aloof" principle (just one tidbit I misunderstood due to my general hatred of this particular author).
P.S. Does anyone else have the times for these comments display 3 hours earlier than you're posting them, or is it just my Google time settings? In the case that it applies to everyone... are our comments actually due at 4 A.M. ;)?
*3 A.M.
Over the past weeks of endless class discussions pertaining to the “rules” of being a good reader; my viewpoint has dramatically changed. Ever since I was little all I have ever heard from teachers is that I need to read slowly and pick out the important details, but in order to be a great reader one must do much more! Not only do we need to pick out the important details we must also fondle them, and find the true meaning behind the writers words. Another idea that interested me was how we must reread. It is amazing how much you can miss by reading a text only one time. Our minds are geared to only pick out the main points and main ideas, but many of times the small details can develop and define a story. Overall, my ideas and viewpoints on what a great reader must do have changed dramatically over the past weeks.
First of all...I am late. My bad.
Second off:
After the first full week of school, I am intrigued by the "requirements" many hold for readers. I guess for myself, I followed the basic rule of thumb-"Never judge a book by it's cover." But now, go ahead and judge the cover, the author, and the details of the book...just don't relate yourself to the characters in the book!
Looking over my notes, I can understand the arguments made by Nabokov. His article was fairly interesting to me regarding writers. As Reid pointed out, you have to be a rereader to be a great reader...to "fondle" the details (Miss Stump). Obviously there is more to learn about the readers and how to continue growing and maturing as a reader...but that is to come!
Here are a few comments for the good of the cause—the cause being your grades as well as your sense of humor. Please note that you may need to use your newly acquired critical reading skills to discern which of these comments should be taken seriously and which should be abandoned after a good laugh.
1.Let us all remember to turn on the spell check/grammar check in our heads. Know does not equal no. Remember, you can write your blog in Word and then paste it into the blog comment box. And now that I’ve ridiculed all of you for said errors, let us hope that my blog is error-free!
2.Asking rhetorical questions—as many of you did—is always a good idea, assuming, of course, that they are written in regards to the topic at hand. Certainly, continue this type of dialogue that many of you created by actually answering others’ questions.
3.Making connections to current events is a great idea—even if your examples are always political ones.
4.Contrary to potentially popular belief, you will not receive extra credit for posting more than once, especially if your second blog is an exact replica of the first!
5.Keep a calendar handy to remember which day of the week it is.
6.Always use details to support your assertions. If you say that annotating has helped you become a good reader, then give an example.
7.Even if someone posts first (such as Katherine) with an awesome blog (nicely done, great analysis of the cartoon), don’t be afraid to tackle that one too.
Post a Comment