Wednesday, September 3, 2008

Trimester One, Blog Two (due 9/7 by midnight)

As a change from last week’s blog, please respond this week using option #2, #3, or #4 on your blog guidelines. This allows you some room for creativity in your answer, especially option #4, which directs you to draw your inspiration from class discussion (perhaps you want to further elaborate on the worms in "To His Coy Mistress"). Reread the blog options!

Here’s a thought to add (moment of brilliance for Stump): Consider finding your own cartoon—political or otherwise—and include the link to it. Then, pose your own questions for the class.

19 comments:

Anonymous said...

While sitting in class and observing the discussion over "To His Coy Mistress," I realized that I am reluctant to giving my own opinions. So I am going to lay out what I annotated on "To His Coy Mistress."
In the beginning of the poem, he talks of his shy/hesitant lady and the love he offers to her. Throughout the poem, I noted six instances where the narrator speaks of how their time is short together. However, even though their time is short, he will love her until the end of time--"Love you ten years before the Flood/Till the conversion of the Jews." Also, with his slow-growing "vegetable love," by saying "time's winged chariot hurrying near;" he is realizing that the time for their love is now, and they should run with it; just as time is galloping away. Her shy character is obvious in the poem just by the narrator's pleading phrases to accept his love. In the end of the poem, he ends with another quote relating to the time he desires for with his mistress; "Thus, though we cannot make our sun/Stand still, yet we will make him run."

Unknown said...

As in depth of a discussion we had over the poem “Home Burial” during class, there is only so much that we can talk about during that one hour time period. Our discussion sparked many ideas in my mind that remained unspoken. One issue that we discussed in class but didn’t give much detail over was that of the wife fearing her husband. In my opinion, the husband’s overbearing disposition was enough to instill feelings of fear in his wife. This is made evident in several lines of the poem. “He said to gain time: ‘What is it you see,’/ Mounting until she cowered under him.” This line in the poem obviously portrays the fear Amy feels towards her husband. Another example is in line thirty-three, where it says, “She withdrew, shrinking from beneath his arm/ That rested on the banister…” Unfortunately, this woman is unable to realize the true motives of her husband. While it is obvious that he is trying to save their relationship, his actions seem unloving to her and therefore she immediately shuts down when he is near. This husband and wife’s relationship is suffering from an inability to understand each other, and until they realize that, the relationship will falter.

Kelsey said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Kelsey said...

Well, I will admit that in class I pretty much remain silent. Mostly, it is because I am still building confidence in myself and my abilities to thrive in an AP course.
During our discussion of "Home Burial", I had a few thoughts. First, it seemed like most everyone was choosing sides. Either the husband was in the wrong, or the wife was. In my opinion, however, they were both wrong. The wife doesn't really give him any room. She accuses him in line 76 of not having any feelings. "If you had any feelings, you that dug with your own hand-how could you?-..." Yet, she seems to me to be the one who is holding in how she feels, cowering from him and not sharing her feelings until this moment readers see in the poem. Does this make him right and her wrong? Or vice versa? I do not believe so; I believe they both could handle the situation in a much better way.
As most girls would tend to side with the wife in this particular situation, if I were to choose sides, I would be on the husband's. Seeing first hand in more than one situation of almost the same type of relationship, it has been my observation that it is very frustrating for the party who feels pushed away. The way I interpreted this poem, at least, I came to the conclusion that the husband has been pushed away for quite some time now. That could possibly be the source of his frustration which becomes apparent in line 64 when he says, "Give me my chance./I do think, though, you overdo it a little." This may seem offensive to those who "side" with the wife, but who is to say she has not offended him in a way we were not allowed to see in this poem? Like Shawn said, it is not the writer’s job, nor his/her obligation to provide each and every detail that would allow an interpretation of their work to be an easy conclusion to come to.
This happens to be my interpretation of this poem. Maybe including a personal experience isn't very objective, which I know is something I should strive for as a critical reader, but the picture that was painted for me has caused me to come to this conclusion, wrong or right.

Unknown said...

I had many thoughts regarding the poem "Home Burial" but in class I never took the opportunity to say anything. My first thought was when we were talking about if the wife was physically afraid of her husband, and I think yes she was. I agreed with the points that were brought up in class, the wife cowering below the husband, the wife shrinking below his arm, but I also noticed a part in the poem that was not mentioned, but I thought was pretty crucial. In the 41st line, the husband says, "... I won't come down the stairs." To me, when he says this, its as if he needs to reassure her of this, or she will leave. If she was not truely scared of him, he would not have to convince her that he wasn't going to come near her in order to get her to talk.
Another thing that I did not agree with was when we were discussing line 115, "Amy! There's someone coming down the road." I thought that he was merely trying to distract her. It seemed like he thought that they had covered enough in the conversation, and he thought that if he distracted her, she would not leave. Apparently he picked the wrong time and place to distract her like that.

Jill Focht said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Jill Focht said...

Relative to the lively class discussion over "Home Burial" I would like to examine the "sides" that develop through the poem. Both the husband and the wife seem to be at fault in the lack of communication in terms of their feelings. Throughout the poem, the husband seems heartless and cold by the way he tries to mask his emotions in such a painful time. But doesn't every man do this at some point in his life when similar situations arise? Hiding is sometimes easier than facing the truth head on. While he could've shown more sensitivity towards his wife he is acting the only way he knows how. While examining this poem furthur it is evident that sides develop which I find interesting. Do you think Robert Frost wrote this poem with the intention of making the reader choose a side? If so, why?

Anonymous said...

As I sat back in class it was very interesting to see the class take sides on the discussion of the “Home Burial.” Just as Kelsey mentioned it seemed as if the class took sides on the argument and it was the husband vs the wife. Naturally, the girls in the class came behind the wife and supported her every word, and the few guys in the class gave a feeble attempt to support the husband. Since I found this very interesting I did not get a chance to support my side of the story because I was very intent on just listening.

As the poem progressed it was evident that the husband and the wife both had different approaches on how the grieve after the lose of their son. Most of the discussion seems to focus on the husbands feelings. Although everyone said that he was being inconsiderate and naive to the situation; I personally believe that he was a complete opposite. I believe that he was trying to stay strong during the tragic lose of his son. Have you ever met someone that never seems to cry or ever show their emotions? Well I believe this particular man is that type of person. If everyone showed their emotions in the same way this world would be one boring place.

Unknown said...

Home Burial definitely sparked a lot of thoughts and various perceptions, and due to this I really didn't know how to formulate my own thoughts and opinions. To start off with I want to revisit many people's opinion that the wife was afraid of her husband. I believe that her fear was created by her own thoughts and that her husband never threatened her with physical harm. I believe in his attempts to communicate to his "brick wall" of a wife he appears to be frightful. But in actuality he's not he's just trying to figure out her problems. In line 65 when he says, "I do think, though, you overdo it a little.", I believe that he sees how his wife is afraid of him and her lack of communication and his frustration of those two things drives him to say that. Then later on when he says "I won't come down the stairs." I think he's just reassuring her she doesn't need to be afraid of him. Why else would he say that?

Anonymous said...

As far as our in class discussion of "Home Burial" goes, I have to say, I still disagree with the vast majority of our class. I find the husband rather intimidating and a bit threatening, as well. I agree with what Jill said in regards to the lack of communication on both sides, but something about the man's tone (at least the tone I perceived) didn't seem quite right to me. And Jill--yes, I do think Frost wanted his readers to choose sides. I think the reader was supposed to identify with one character or the other. Perhaps this is what I did, and that affected my interpretation of the poem.
I also to have to say, I disagree pretty strongly with Reid. I don't think the girls supported every word the woman spoke. I felt that we acknowledged her fault in the lack of communication and discussed what she could have done differently to avoid the conflict that erupted throughout the poem. Also- I think in a committed relationship, such as a marriage, you have to kind of do away with pretenses and all emotional armor. Maybe when he was trying to "stay strong," he should have just said what he felt. The people who don't show any emotion are often perceived as cold and unfeeling, which is definitely what his wife felt.
Harlan, I like your description of the wife as a brick wall. Maybe it's fitting...

Anonymous said...

When talking about "Home Burial" I have to agree with Jill when she said, "Throughout the poem, the husband seems heartless and cold by the way he tries to mask his emotions in such a painful time. But doesn't every man do this at some point in his life when similar situations arise? Hiding is sometimes easier than facing the truth head on." Men, in general, attempt to create a false facade when dealing with emotional times. Women tend to overreact to the way men cope with pain, as seen in the poem numerous times. In response to Jill's question, I do not believe Frost created this poem for people to take sides. I think he was attempting to show the differences between a man and woman's ways of dealing with losses.
In lines 93 and 94 the husband states, "I shall laugh the worst laugh I ever laughed./I'm cursed. God, if I don't believe I'm cursed." Does he say this because he does not like what his wife is saying?

Chuck Norris has brass cahonas said...

Although this was not my first intention, i, much like kelsey, will reamin quiet during class. i am now going to absorb everything everyone else says and then elaborate on their thoughts in my writing. i first attempted this on friday and found that i learned much more than usual about the poems we've been reading, "Home Burial" in perticular.
There was a great amount of class discussion over this poem. This was because Robert Frost allowed for opinions to be formed on the side of either party. Like Kelsey said, many students in our class sided either with the man or the woman. After hearing arguements from students supporting each side, i believe that the true problem lies with both the man and the woman. To be a successful couple, you have to be able to work through tough situations by understanding one another. The man should not have told the woman she was "overdoing" it, but the woman should have been more receptive of the mans apologee. The problem with guys is (and im taking a stab at my own machismo here people) they have plenty of emotion but are sometimes afraid to show in sentimental way. This, of course, can be interpeted by women as an act of no feeling whatsoever. Having said that, women have tendencies to harbor anger towards men and not be as receptive to apologees. These two "theories" of mine are what i believe cause the most problems between the couple in the poem.

VivaVoce said...

One of the poems I was not too sure about was "To His Coy Mistress". Listening to other people's opinions helped me understand the true meaning of the poem. Although in line 27 & 28, "My echoing song; then worms shall try that long preserved virginity..." was humorous and somewhat disgusting, I think we must look at the rest of his words, not just concentrate on one or two lines. Obviously, this man has a deep love for his mistress. In lines 13-20, he is in awe of her body and gives praises to every part of her. He is so desperate to be with her because they have such a short time together. Although this is mostly about him wanting to have sex with her, we could look at it as just a love letter to his almost lover. His love is sure, but hers is shy and this poem is just a plead for her love, not her body.

kinz said...

After reading (and rereading) the various interesting ideas posted by my peers about Robert Frost's Home Burial, I too feel obligated to voice (or rather type) my opinions. In regard to Jill's seemingly straightforward yet intriguingly complicated question, I believe that Frost wrote with the intention of tearing his readers apart by creating emotional conflict. The poem portrays the communal melancholy of grief, immediately establishing an opportunity for the audience to relate to the characters. After creating an opening for this connection, Frost provides two stereotypical responses to the raw emotion, making the readers want to choose sides based on their own personal reactions. A problem arises, however, as the story evolves and presents both sides with understandable rationale. While it might seem typical that a man might respond to deep hurt by forcing himself to remain aloof, it is equally fathomable for a woman to want a show of emotion and support, just as Amy did. As the poem continues, the authentic depictions of BOTH sides causes the reader to jump back and forth because EACH reaction conveyed understandable pros and cons.

Shawn Kronk said...

First off, I want to clear up a point that I felt strongly about, but feel I failed to properly communicate during class. I believe that the conflict in “Home Burial” is due to the faults of both the husband and the wife, and that taking sides is not a very objective approach to the poem. However, I spent much of my time in class defending the husband in order to draw attention to the less apparent faults of Amy. Manifest from the polarized discussion in class and on the blog so far, it is certainly easy for individuals to relate more to one character or another, but to actually side with one character or another quite possibly goes beyond the limits of reading critically.
Secondly – in response to Jill – I think Frost may have had multiple motives in writing his poem in such a manner. As we discovered from our class’s discussion, an initial reading of the poem leads an individual to take sides with one of Frost’s two characters; however, we also discovered a more prevalent, and less prejudice interpretation as we discussed and rethought the poem. This returns to Perrine’s idea of an ‘area of meaning.’ Some individuals may interpret “Home Burial” as a comment on the coldness of men in emotional times; some may interpret it as a comment on the hypersensitivity and inconsolability of women in grief; and some may yet consider it, as did Brodsky, a more in-depth, poetic analysis of the nature, contrast, and interaction of grief and reason. All these interpretations can be supported by the text – all fall within the area of meaning.
Finally, there was a line in the poem that I wasn’t entirely sure what to think of. When the husband says in line 93-94, “‘I shall laugh the worst laugh I ever laughed. / I’m cursed. God, if I don’t believe I’m cursed.’” My first thought was, “Where the heck did that come from, and what does it have to do with anything?” My second thought was much the same… maybe more professionally phrased, but the same general idea. After rereading multiple times, the only thing I could come up with was that it was an exclamation produced by his high level of frustration with not knowing how to comfort his wife. Does anyone else have any thoughts about this passage?

Shawn Kronk said...

And in response to Tabitha's and Jill's comments, I don't believe it's a good idea to generalize either the male or female gender. I don't often say that in class, but it's not what I'd consider a obejective statement. Stereotyping, though a useful literary technique in satire, etc. is not what I would consider a useful assumption in making a critical analysis.

And in regards to Wes, I think if your comments in class were more like what you posted here on the blog, it'd be great to have you adding to class discussion. Who knows, we might all appreciate your thoughts and insights.

Unknown said...

Hey Stump! ... I'm putting this here because it is regards to this class. First of all from what I can see you have a very strong class this year. I got bored and I was wondering how things were going so I went through and read what they had to say. I was very intrigued with what they had to say. Honestly, I think this group is more insightful than our class was last year. It was interesting reading their ideas on the poems and even more so on Perrine and Nabokov (ICK!) and comparing them to what my own ideas were at this point is time last year. It was very interesting to me to see how many of them accepted the ideas ... whereas our class hated them. So I just wanted to commend all of you students, who may read this, for having open minds and learning from the things you are doing. I also wanted to tell you, Stumpy, that it seems like you have a good year ahead of you. I only hope you are lucky enough to have the other classes be as good as this one seems! :) ... ok ... well there's my insight for you! ... I know it wasn't needed ... possibly not even wanted ... but you love me Stumpy and you know it! :) haha! Have a good one! :)

Alaric said...

In response to Wes (sorry Shawn for continued use of stereotypes):

I have to agree with a lot of what you said. We males are too focused on maintaining our macho facade sometimes. However, I don't think that protecting our pride is the only reason males face problems expressing their emotions. Guys, (again, overgeneralizing here), would rather let there problems work themselves out than try to find an immediate solution. In my opinion, many women (again, in general) deal with some problems by over-analyzing them to the point that the problem becomes something more. Because they dwell on their problems this way, women tend to see problems as bigger deals than men do.

Unfortunately, this stereotypical personality trait of women is further accentuated by a man's attempt to ignore the problem completely (as seen in the husband's comments about his rotting fence). Men tend to deal with problems by giving them time to dissipate before they attempt to solve them. Obviously, this attempt can sometimes have unhealthy consequences (evidence of unhealthy consequences). This difference in approaches to the issue of grieving between them then leads to the wife feeling as though the husband is emotionless ("you couldn't care!" and "if you had any feelings..."), and from this misunderstanding spawns the wife's frustration with her husband (and vice-versa).

In response to Shawn and those annoyed by my overgeneralizing and stereotyping:
I agree, stereotypes can easily inhibit ones ability to analyze a work, but I feel like this particular work was based on the afore-mentioned difference in the way men and women stereotypically deal with their emotional problems. Therefore, the work itself is a stereotype of men and women and stereotypical interpretations should be applicable.

Shawn Kronk said...

In response to Jon, taking Brodsky's interpretation of the poem,a stereotype of either gender is entirely coincidental. With the grief vs. reason interpretation, Frost's goal is to explore their relation. The choice to use a man and women to represent reason and grief respectively is a matter of choice. It may seem more natural, and therefore more effective, but if Frost's goal was to explore the interaction and of the two abstractions, he could have done it with any two characters of any gender. Again, it seems to depend on the interpretation of the poem you take.