#1: Respond to the following prompt using one of the four methods described in your blog handout: Continue our class discussion about the identity of the speaker in The Canterbury Tales assumes. Think about the tone as he comments on particular individuals. Do you pick up on any biases? Does this make him reliable/unreliable?
OR
#2: Choose a character from The Canterbury Tales, and compare him or her to a modern figure. Make your comparisons specific, detailed—and appropriate. Feel free to agree or disagree with your classmates’ comparisons.
Wednesday, September 10, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

13 comments:
In the prologue of the Canterbury Tales, the narrator assumes the role of giving us information about the people he is going with on this pilgrimage. Although he gives off the impression that he is an unbiased speaker, it is obvious to the reader that he favors some characters over others. For most of the characters he has a sarcastic tone, and he portrays them defying the stereotype that their character is most commonly associated with. On the other hand, characters such as the knight and the parson are portrayed in a very respectful light. The narrator speaks highly of these men, which is unlike his view of the others in the entourage. Because of this bias, the speaker should be viewed as unreliable in his description of many of his companions. When reading the prologue, the reader must determine on their own whether the information that the narrator is giving is factual or biased.
On the contrary to Jen's comment, I think that the narrator of The Canterbury Tales is reliable. Like she said, the speaker does describe the characters in different ways--showing that he is observant. While the speaker tells of the different characters, he stereotypes almost all. However, with the parson and the knight, he does speak of highly of them because of his respect for them. Therefore, he is not hesitant to say what he really thinks. I think that this information the narrator gives is reliable because of the descriptive details of the characters and the honesty of the narrator.
I would have to agree with Jen. I don't believe the reader should necessarily base their opinions of the characters on what the narrator says. Many people have opinions on many different things, and whether or not they mean for them too be, sometimes their opinions are obvious. If one feels strongly about a certain topic, or in this case, person; it might be difficult not to let it show even a little bit. The narrator does show bias when it comes to describing the others on the pilgrimage. Some he describes in a nice, almost admirable way, while others are described in a less than desirable light. These tend to be the ones who defy their particular stereotype. However, the reader was not there, so they have to take the narrator's word for it. I am not convinced that his version is necessarily the correct one.
I personally agree with Taylor. I consider the narrator to be fairly unbiased, and I think he gives a pretty reliable account of each character. Granted, not every account is a favorable one, but not all people deserve favorable descriptions. Does the friar who takes bribes really need to be cast in a favorable light? I also agree with Taylor's statement that the narrator stereotypes all the characters. Jen is correct in her statement that the narrator speaks highly of the parson and the knight, but despite his obvious regard, I think he still shelves them according to what he perceives. While he perceives a good deal, he does not grasp everything: thus, the stereotypes. Overall, I think the narrator is reliable because he gives a full account of everyone, good and bad.
I have a thought about narrator reliability in relation to historical context. It is apparent that the narrator has a greater respect for the knight. Much of this respect seemed to be for his valiancy in battle. If I’m reading the text properly, phrases like “his lord’s wars” and “both in Christendom and heathen lands” indicate that these battles were part of the Crusades. The question of reliability comes to the respect for these actions. Since the Crusades are largely recognized as a mistake by the Church today, does the author’s respect for such events make him as reliable in today’s context as it would have then? Since we live in a widely Christianized community, I thought I’d throw that out as something to think about. In response to Jen’s comment, I feel that the author (at least surely in the original context of this work) is mostly reliable. Of course, when you consider a work written from the first person perspective, biases will be present and unavoidable. However, I feel that since the narrator describes “What their condition was, the full array / Of each of them, as it appeared to me,” he does his best to be reliable, inserting his own commentary only when he feels it is helpful to the reader. Besides, even if the narrator were unreliable, the reader has no other source of information from which to receive a different account.
I'm going to have to agree with Jenny on the author's bias. Chaucer was quite the fortunate man; even the king went so far as to label him "our beloved valet". Chaucer spent much of his time in the presence of kings, queens, and other royal servants. Because of his social status, I don't believe that Chaucer's description of the lower class characters should be trusted. After all, his view of the average person at that time must have been greatly skewed against them. He was also a man of pristine manners. Therefore, the life of common people must have appeared almost barbaric to him.
Well...it seems we have quite the debate going on here :)
I happen to agree with Taylor's opinion. The author is just telling about the characters without bias. Just because some of the characters are shown in a negative light does not mean he is bias. Stating a fact about someone, good or bad, cannot be counted as bias; it is a fact. I think that because he is simply stating facts about the characters of Canterbury, he is pretty reliable. Now, we might never know if Chaucer made his narrator truthful about the characters, obviously because it is fictional. But in my opinion, he seems to just be stating facts. Granted, he may push the unfavorable facts about some of the people farther than others, but wouldn't any human being do that if they did not like the person?
I would like to share my thoughts relative to the issue of the narrator's reliability in Canterbury Tales. This seems to be a hot topic in the responses of this blog but I don't think this should even be an issue. The unreliable nature of the narrator add to the story's plot line and tone. I find the narrator to be rather engaging and captivating and the questionable opinions he or she has add to that engagement. His very "human" approach to the character's descriptions makes the story more real and alive. He shares his very honest and blunt opinions about each character which other pieces of literature don't have. Rather than an omniscient genius for a narrator, this unreliable human gives a new perspective to the prominent characters of that era. He reveals secrets (or even truths) about each one in a way that adds humor and enlightenment for the reader. I like the narrator's unreliable nature because its real and gritty and frankly more entertaining.
When trying to form an opinion of the narrator's reliability in the Canterbury tales, I tend to jump back and forth. As many have priorly pointed out, Chaucer indeed describes certain characters more favorably than others, which make his personal opinions apparent throughout the prologue and provide a means of swaying the readers' views. He also, however, gives each character a fairly lengthy description, showing that he wants the readers to find interest in each character equally. As Shawn shows us, Chaucer informs the reader in the beginning that he is decribing each character "as it appeared to me." By stating this, Chaucer ensures that we cannot only hold him accountable for straight facts, just for his views of the particular situation. I also think it is important that we realize that the story happened in the past, and the narrator is describing the scenario purely from memory. Memories most often contain skewed details or lack them entirely.
I believe the speaker attempts to be unbias when describing the different characters. He even says, "...I speak plainly and with no concealings,/ And give account of all their words and dealings,/ Using their very phrases as they fell." This shows he desires to state how the people really are and what the truly have to say. I do believe he is slightly bias. The speaker shows favortism to people like the knight and the parson. This liking might be because they are people of high esteem; the knight has faught in many major battles, and the parson is devoted to God. I am not sure whether to pin the speaker as reliable or unreliable. When describing the people I think he might be unreliable because he likes some people more then others. When stating a character's story he is more reliable, because he attempts to relay the information as it is stated.
I think that Chaucer was very biased in his tales. I agree with Taylor on the fact that he seems to speak more highly of the knight than he does about some of the other characters. Although he is biased, I also think that his account is reliable. Even though he shows favoritism towards some of the characters, he does provide a truthful account of what happened. He just liked some of the other characters better, apparently. His account is also reliable because it is the only account given. There are no historical facts to disagree or argue with his statements.
Well I am just going to jump right in and join this heated debate haha….
I would personally have to agree with Taylor on this topic. I feel as if the speaker is honest and reliable in his descriptions. Although he may exemplify the knight as an honorable character and almost use sarcasm towards other characters, I feel as if all of this is very necessary. If the speaker were to speak highly of every character the descriptions would tend to be rather boring after awhile. Even though many may argue that the narrator is unreliable, he speaks in intense detail while he describes each character and I feel that although all of his descriptions may not be “crowd pleasing” they are accurate.
In regards to the speaker in Canterbury Tales, i believe that, because i pick up on the biases, he can be equally reliable and unreliable. In class i mentioned that his reasonings for favoring one character over the other could be that he fears some characters more than others. He holds the knight and his associates in high regard because the knight is an intimidating figure. He also describes the parson and his brother with respect because they are men of god (the friar is also a man of god but obviously hes got some odd motives). These fears may have caused the speaker to overexagerate the qualities of these characters. In contrast, other characters such as, the fiar, nun, scholar, or woman, are ridiculed because they pose no threat to the speaker. As a side note: i find it very interesting that the speaker is passing such judgements on these people while the journey they are making is for religious regions. Who is he to openly judge?
Post a Comment